News
EdFutures News
EdFutures News
10 Oct, 2024
13 : 55
Twenty-one YWIES Shanghai Gubei students were making final preparations for their special presentations at the exhibition hall of the College of Architecture and Urban Planning, Tongji University. Some students double-checked the placement of their design models and explanatory panels, trying to make sure that every line was perfect. Others sat in a corner, practicing their speeches in whispered voices.
From mid-November 2023 to April 2024, the students had enrolled in a special architectural design course. Their presentations about what they had learned marked the final stage of the programme. The students' architectural models included a white pottery museum, a dodecahedral rock museum, a glass spherical botanical garden, and exhibition halls and museums featuring themes such as Buddhism, parrots, and music.
In addition to YCYW teachers including Dr Christopher Hurley, Head of EdFutures Division, and Mr Douglas Woodruff, Western Co-Principal of YWIES Shanghai Gubei, three professors from the College of Architecture and Urban Planning at Tongji University served as judges to evaluate the students' work and offer advice.
During the presentations, 11 groups of students took turns explaining their designs. They covered various aspects, such as the functional positioning of the exhibition halls, site selection, and introduction of the design scheme. In addition to their elaborate architectural models, the students also prepared detailed explanatory panels documenting the entire design process. These panels included hand-drawn sketches, foam block models, and solid models, as well as detailed explanations and handwritten design inspirations.
The judges were impressed by the students' creativity and the high level of their completed work. The students were able to produce work that typically would be expected only of university architecture students.
The judges remained impartial, even though they were dealing with high school students. Sara, one of the students, had been inspired by a childhood trip to Singapore, and designed a glass spherical botanical garden. After Sara’s presentation, Associate Professor Tan Zheng asked her about how the design would balance the needs of both plants and people and their different requirements for temperature and humidity in the environment. Assistant Professor Qu Zhang reminded the students to consider the scale of their designs, such as whether a sphere could accommodate 5 or 50 people.
"It was a great opportunity for our students to develop their presentation skills and learn how to effectively communicate the highlights of their projects. The Tongji professors listened carefully to each presentation and gave either positive or critical comments from a professional point of view. Both positive and critical feedback are valuable learning experiences that prepare our students for the real world," said Ms Trill Zhang, the teacher in charge of the Architecture Programme and Integrator of the EdFutures Division.
According to Professor Zhang Peng, Vice Dean of the College of Architecture and Urban Planning, while there are still many aspects of the students' designs that need improvement, technical skills can be developed. The students' innate enthusiasm for creativity and their creative thinking, however, are precious and require diligent nurturing.
Ms Trill Zhang is a registered architect, and thus understands the complexity of architecture, which involves both engineering and humanities. When the EdFutures Division planned to collaborate with YWIES Shanghai Gubei to offer an architecture course in the school's Future Lab programme last November, she made it clear that the course would not focus on mastering specialised, technical architectural knowledge. Instead, it would focus on architectural design as a means to explore multiple perspectives on various issues, in order to inspire future learning and the career directions of the students.
During the first half of the course, Ms Zhang introduced the students to basic architectural concepts and the physics related to architecture, including the principles of natural and artificial light and how such could shape spaces and affect human experiences within the spaces. One student was particularly interested in this topic and spent an entire afternoon and evening experimenting. He used paper to make different shapes and then shone a flashlight on them to explore how the spaces would appear under different angles of light. Ms Zhang noted, "We are always looking for highlights like these in the learning process."
In addition to teaching basic architectural concepts, Ms Zhang collaborated with the school's physics teacher Mr Quinn An, digital media teacher Mr William Ordonez, and music teacher Ms Renee Wu to integrate multiple disciplines and to help students understand of the future direction of multidisciplinary learning. In the later stages of the modelling process, Mr Hubert Hu from the EdFutures Division taught the students how to connect electrical circuits to the models, so as to introduce artificial light into the architectural space.
For example, Ms Zhang introduced the students to the design of the West Bund Museum in Shanghai, which is full of classical order, and discussed with Ms Renee Wu about how architecture could have some type of connection to music. They selected Beethoven’s "Violin Sonata No. 5 in F Major, Op. 24 'Spring': IV. Rondo" (Allegro ma non troppo). They asked the students to choose a part of this music, find a location in the museum that seems to correspond to the melody, and describe their emotions.
"We encountered a range of emotional descriptions, such as open, bright, dim, and tense. These initial feelings are precious yet fleeting in any field of art and creativity. Through this class, the students were able to pay attention to these easily overlooked emotions and effectively express them," she recalled.
In his speech at the event, Professor Zhang Peng asked the students: "What is design?" Some students responded with "avant-garde," "superb," and "stylish," while others said that design reflects a person's personality. Professor Zhang's own answer emphasised that design should be unique, artistic, functional, and related to people. He also noted that architectural design is not just a profession, but something that is relevant to all of us, every day.
Ms Trill Zhang explained the reason for choosing "museum or art gallery" as the theme for the final project. The goal was to use this relatively simple design space to inspire the high school students to think about what type of art career they hoped to pursue, what artworks they wanted to create, and the kind of spatial atmosphere they sought to evoke.
One student, Jonathan, designed a Buddhist museum, and carefully explained his design during his presentation. As the sun changes during the day, the sunlight will shine on the large Buddha's hand at the front of the museum, on the Buddha statues in the museum, and then illuminate their heads of the Buddha statues. This will enable visitors to feel the compassion and serenity of Buddhism.
Jonathan believes that architectural design is not merely functional but also an expression of culture and emotion. The shaping of space can give life to a building and make the cold stone and steel seem warm and inviting. "I hope that my designs can help people to experience the beauty that architecture creates and to feel the harmonious relationship of architecture with nature, society, and culture. For me, architectural design is not only a profession; it is also a way to observe and understand the world," he explained.
While appreciating the high level of Jonathan's completed work, the judges advised him to develop his own style instead of relying on multiple architectural languages and symbols. In response, Jonathan said that he hopes to find the right balance and style in his own designs through these imitations.
After the project presentations, the students participated in Associate Professor Cen Wei's design workshop. One of the tasks was to design a "catio", an outdoor activity space for cats. When asked if this task catered to the students' love of cats, he explained that current designs are created from the perspective of humans and emphasise human emotions. In the future, however, the perspective for designing a space might change. What if we explored space from a cat's point of view?
For the students in the architecture course, their design journeys are just beginning. Their project presentations provided opportunities to grasp the difference between ideas and reality, and Associate Professor Cen's assignment to design a "catio" offered limitless expansion of their future possibilities. After all, a designer's mission is to think about future trends and how people will live in the future.
The students' architecture design models will be on display at the TEDxYouth@YCYWShanghai event on 15 June. You are welcome to visit the booth and learn about the students' design aspirations.